Auntie's 90th Birthday – A Hearty Defence of the BBC

bbc scandal

The bottom of this article has a song which basically sums up my defence, even though I first heard it after writing the sodding piece.

The British have a problem. Over the past few years they have learned, legitimately, that almost every single nationwide institution has been corrupted.

Worldwide, the discovery that the banks were corrupted wasn't exactly a shock to most people's public confidence, but what the bankers did to the world was just the beginning for what the UK was about to discover.

The train wreck began in 2009 when the Daily Telegraph exposed a scandal to do with Members of Parliament (not a government scandal, as MPs from all over the House were involved) fiddling their expenses claims. It has hurt many politicians, and virtually obliterated any public trust in government. Even though we have since changed governments, the current Cameron Coalition isn't exactly enjoying the story. Damage incurred: resignation, dismissal, and arrest and imprisonment of various MPs; devastated public confidence.

Next came the newspapers, focusing on (but not entirely) the Murdoch tabloids. Turns out it was common practice to hack into the voicemails of virtually anybody in order to obtain a story. Mainly this practice was used to get dirt on celebrities, but the example that people find most sickening is the Milly Dowler case. Milly Dowler was a teenager who was murdered in 2002, and prior to the discovery of her body, a phone hacker by the name of Glen Mulcaire had accessed her voicemails, deleted some messages, and used the rest for a story. This deletion of messages ultimately led Milly's parents to believe she was still alive and using her phone somewhere. Damage incurred: as well as the torture the Dowlers experienced at the hands of Mulcaire and the tabloids, the privacy of many individuals abused; the closure of News of the World; oh and total loss of public confidence.

Police next. For this, we return to a dark part of Britain's history that took place in 1989. The Hillsborough disaster is so named because of a human crush that killed 96 people during a semi-final FA cup soccer match between Liverpool and Nottingham Forest. Essentially this disaster was a culmination of a poorly designed stadium and a breakdown in communications. In September 2012, once and for all, it was concluded that the police were ultimately responsible. Why is this a scandal and not just a tragedy? Because ever since 1989, the police officers in charge named the Liverpool fans as the people at fault. It has since been discovered that any witness statements taken in 1989 blaming the police were destroyed. A mass in-house cull of evidence took place. Now thousands of police officers are being investigated. Damage incurred: as well as the 96 deaths (plus three suicides in following years), the false blame of innocent Liverpool fans who have been the subject of prejudice ever since; one of the largest independent investigations ever carried out; and total and utter loss of public confidence.

By now you're no doubt noticing a theme. State and independent institutions with too much corruption are being slowly brought to account through various committees and hearings. A fictional version of this involving MI6 even becomes a main plot point of Skyfall.

So the pattern is already there: Institution – Scandal – Deeper Scandal – Hearing – Resolution – Loss of Public Confidence.

This is a problem in itself. For now the BBC has been embroiled in its own scandal of similar proportions, and the pattern we've established means that is where the BBC may end up – a conclusion that is entirely wrong. This has made global news so I'll be brief – but essentially for decades a BBC presenter by the name of Jimmy Savile was able to abuse hundreds, I'll say again, hundreds of children. He lived up to the last four letters of his name, and died in 2011 without prosecution. When he died, the gushing and now-regretted tributes came in and only now are victims able to come forward.

The story is still developing, with the BBC's Director General stepping down after only 54 days on the job. It's a massive story, raising the question of what people knew and what they merely suspected without evidence, what stories were blocked from broadcast and what stories should have been blocked, what people were involved with Jimmy Savile and what people have been falsely accused. Explaining this story is too difficult, so I'll summarise and say I'm defending the BBC here for five reasons.

Firstly, the BBC's main fault here is a lack of cohesive leadership. Sure it needs reviewing, criticising, even reforming. No question something has gone wrong, but we should fix what has gone wrong, not pander to our reactionary selves and hate it while the hatred's fashionable.

Secondly, it's not just the BBC involved in this scandal. First to get the punishment was the National Health Service for allowing Jimmy Savile such close access to children in their care, but in truth we're either all to blame or none of us are. In Britain Jimmy Savile was a popular man. He was knighted by the Queen for services to charity. His image as a tracksuit-wearing loner added to a bizarre double-bluff and one which millions fell for – i.e. he looked and indeed was a creep. Only Jimmy Savile is responsible for his crimes, and with only his corpse and a trashed grave remaining we're after more blood.

Thirdly, this story is largely being bolstered by the Murdoch tabloids not because of what happened, but because of the coverage the BBC gave to their phone-hacking scandal. This, in short, is their ugly revenge.

Fourthly, the BBC is a good thing.
The newspapers are less about news and more about campaigns and slurs. It's Fox News in print.
As I'll say again with the police and the Members of Parliament, but what I will not say of the tabloids. Britain needs the British Broadcasting Corporation, just as much as it needs a government and a police force. Of course there needs to be a free press, but currently there are many newspapers which fail to provide such a service. The newspapers are less about news and more about campaigns and slurs. It's Fox News in print. But Britain needs a state broadcaster, capable of transcending political bias (granted, not always succeeding but always trying) and capable of delivering gold.

Fifthly, the BBC had its 90th birthday this week. On November 14th 1922 its first ever broadcast, the famed 2LO, reached Britain's brand-new radios. Frankly we should owe her a little more respect on this week of all weeks.

With this in mind, I give you Mitch Benn's "I'm Proud of the BBC". Although this particular birthday is a rocky one for the BBC, a nation thanks Auntie, and wishes her a happy 90th.

have your say

Copyright © Superbious.com and Steven Sutton 2012-2013 All Rights Reserved.
latest in Political

Is the West to blame for Ukraine?
In a recent article at the foreignaffairs.com, John J. Mearsheimer blames the West and the U.S. in the problems in Ukraine. He says that Putin, in thi...

Welcome to Egypt
When you're thinking about Egypt and its current turmoil, consider this - the country is split into 4 somewhat balanced powers, almost equal in their ...

Canadian Gov't Gives Special Treatment to Private Corporation, Canadians Ecstatic!
Not that this hasn't happened before in Canadian economic & political history, but I digress. Verizon, a notably powerful ISP, TV, and Phone provider ...
latest in Legal

An End to the Marijuana Prohibition?
With weed being legalized recreationally in two states (though one with many restrictions), will weed someday be federally legal?

The Sick Truth Behind Washington’s Attempt to Legalize Pot
Initiative 502 will actually make Cannabis more illegal by legalizing it. The driving policies especially could end up sending innocent people to jail...

The case of Mapp v. Ohio
In this outstanding case, the parties were the following: first as plaintiff, then as respondent was Ohio State, and on the other side first as defen...
latest in Religious

I see the Pope
I see the Pope’s name in the headlines quite a bit recently, and I know that a lot of people, even those outside of the Catholic Church, think he is a...

Scientology in the Classroom?
European school systems have a long tradition of mandated religious education, which is becoming more difficult to implement as growing religious dive...

In Gosh We Trust
Holy cow! My word! Jiminy Crickets! When something surprising or unbelievable happens, what's your go-to phrase of exclamation?
latest in OP

The Interview
I’ve wanted to watch The Interview since May, when I was sitting in a movie theater and I saw a preview for the Seth Rogen and James Franco film about...

Let's Face It, We're War Criminals
Says Cheney, "I would do it again in a minute." I'm sure he means, "I will do it again in a minute," referring to torture. How else is he supposed to ...

September 11 - We Will Forget
A report was released Tuesday last week on the myriad methods used by the CIA and other intelligence agencies to extract certain information from al Q...
latest in Noidea

Juvie For A 10-Year-Old
According to FoxNews.com, two males brought weapons onto their school campus with a plot to kill a classmate.

The Helpless Canadian
The Trials and Tribulations of the Helpless Canadian

Former Holmes Fluffer Worried about Health of Jeremy's Penis
She spoke out couple of days ago on her fears that the porn industry's signature phallus might be eroding in stature.

Read only articles by writers that match your criteria.

Enter your email address for Daily Superbious Digest

Delivered by FeedBurner

more popular stories
Has racism evolved?

The Sick Truth Behind Washington’s Attempt to Legalize Pot

Communism in America Part 1: The End of the World as We Know It

How to survive the binge drinking generation

Political Correctness, in Film Reviews!

An End to the Marijuana Prohibition?

Cyprus Needs to Happen, So Stop Crying like a Bitch

Dr. Keith Ablow, Accidental Psychiatrist, Plays Armchair Psychiatrist Instead

Really? James Dobson blames gays, abortion for shootings

An in-depth look at the mental disorder called "Politics"

Working with the Public: A Guide to Losing Faith in Humanity

Dumb Ingredients for a Dumber Consumer

How close is Big Brother?

United State of Whatever

Climate Change, Climate Shmange

What the Hippies Taught America and How Occupy Didn’t Listen

President Obama is a Racist

The Lesser of Two Evils

In Gosh We Trust

Boy Scouts Are Gay

Ohio Middle School Promotes Religions

Buckle Your Bible-Belt

Rape in America

News Corp. Secretly Romances Monopoly

The True Tragedy of Amanda Todd

The Anti-Bullying Movement: Fools and...Bullies?

What is the perfect man?

The Constitution: A Long Overdue Retirement

Religion in Politics

The Second Greatest Story Ever Told

Skewed perceptions of beauty

The "Canada Economic Action Plan" is a Sham

Libertarianism: The Cult

Working with the Public: A Guide to Losing Faith in Humanity

Should the government do more to discourage cigarette smoking?

What We (Should Have) Learned From Sandusky

Canada: For Sale; Dictatorships Save Big!

Tow Our Line or Get The F*ck Out!

Superbious.com cartoon: Rorsarch Test

Keystones and Drones


SUPERBIOUS is an e-zine, online creature or politically incorrect blog, created to make Us happy. We have lots to say and we simply needed someone to say it to. Hopefully you'll find it more than readable. Or not.

So you want to write?

Have something politically incorrect to say, yet something that has a point in it? Well, maybe, just maybe we could hear from you.

write for us
Our friends

...yeeeeees, we love Fox News. But we love Jon Stewart and Bill Maher a lot better. Fox News we love because of the quality, amusing, factual information they provide. Bill and Jon we love because they help us see it.

Politics Blogs

My Zimbio
get in touch

You can contact us via , Superbious Facebook or Superbious Twitter account.

If you want to syndicate our content, see this page.